The first time this theme got rejected, the problem was related to the fold devices, so I removed them to see if that was all, 14-15 days later it got rejected again with a new issue on something that wasn’t mentioned before
[Defect] Circle is truncated (Settings) -- [Procedure] 1. Apply Theme 2. Settings / Display / Dark mode settings 3. Check the screen
Here’s an image of the defect, the preview and the file on my computer.
As you can see there’s no problems on the preview. Reducing the icon size could fix the problem, but that’s not ideal.
I can’t guarantee that reducing the size of the images would solve anything, I didn’t had this problem with my other theme and they got approved, but it was released a few months ago using another version of GTS, it was before the 2023 ver. The other theme’s icons were used as a base when I made this one.
The main problem here is that it looks like that after too many days, if the reviewers find a single problem they end the test, reject and report instead of reporting all the issues at once. It wouldn’t be so troublesome if the review process didn’t take so long or they would report all the problems at once, but like this it is impracticable.
Another major issue is that the first time this theme got rejected it seemed that at the end of the day the issue wasn’t for something that I did, and this time once again it doesn’t seem like the issue was caused for something that I did and was caused by a glitch on the GTS, the Samsung UI or on the Android.
I might try converting this theme to 2022 to see if it works, I don’t really feel like removing these Icons. That and I’ll probably stop changing every single icon that I can change for my next themes, if it get’s rejected for a reason like “You didn’t change every single thing”, there’s not much I can do about it if they don’t work properly.
For reference, this is the post I made when this theme got rejected for the first time.